This selection is protected by copyright and is not available online. The Selection Snapshot has been provided in its place.
Go to page
DURING READING
Guiding
Comprehension
10 Target Skill Fact and Opinion
• Inferential
"Dreams of Flight" is David Botello's best work. Is this a statement of fact or opinion? How do you know?
This is a statement of opinion. It cannot be proven true or false. It is someone's belief.
Monitor Progress
then… use the skill and strategy instruction on
p. 347.
If… students are unable to differentiate between statements of fact and opinion,
Target Skill Fact and Opinion
11 Paraphrase • Inferential
In your own words, tell the meaning of David Botello's mural "Dreams of Flight."
Possible response: "Dreams of Flight" encourages students to believe in themselves and follow their dreams.
Target Skill SKILLS
STRATEGIES IN CONTEXT
Fact and Opinion Answer Questions
TEACH
  • Remind students that a fact can be proven true or false. When reading, we must decide if a statement is fact or opinion. Then we should decide if facts are true or false.
  • State a fact about the weather
    that is false, such as "It is 120°
    outside." Ask students to
    determine whether the
    statement is a fact or opinion.
    Lead them to recognize that the
    statement is a fact, but it is
    false. You can read a thermometer to check the accuracy of the statement.
  • Model distinguishing between
    statements of fact and statements of opinion.
Think Aloud MODEL I read a statement and ask myself, "Can it be proven true or false?" It cannot be proven to be true or false if there is no source to prove or disprove it. It is not a statement of fact. Then I ask myself, "Is the statement someone's belief that can be supported, but cannot be proven true or false?" Yes, it is someone's belief. I may agree or disagree with the statement, but it cannot be proven true or false.
PRACTICE AND ASSESS
Have students identify a statement of fact from pp. 346–347. (Possible response: Statement of fact: David painted a large mural called "Dreams of Flight."
Talking Walls: Art for the People

"Talking Walls: Art for the People"
by Katacha Díaz

Student Edition
Unit 6, pp. 336–349

Expository nonfiction provides factual information. What information do you get from this Selection Snapshot?

The United States is a nation of immigrants. People from many countries left their native lands and came to America. They settled here, hoping to find a better life and to enjoy American freedoms. America offers its people many freedoms including the freedom of artistic expression. Here people are free to express themselves through music, dance, and art.
In many places art can be found on the walls of buildings. Artists are hired to paint large murals as public art. They paint indoors or outdoors. Some paintings show the history of a place. Others show festivals or symbols of American freedom and democracy. Most are in bright, vibrant colors. All are art for the people to see.
One such mural is called "Immigrant." It covers the wall of a meat market in Los Angeles and shows Latin American immigrants. One is trying to reach the Statue of Liberty. In the mural are workers and their families. A young mother walks with her family, and a man sells bags of oranges on the street. The mural was painted by Hector Ponce, an immigrant from El Salvador.
Joshua Sarantitis is another muralist. He works with local people to plan murals for their communities. First he talks with the people and encourages them to tell about their neighborhoods. Then he draws a sketch and plans his mural. "Reach High and You Will Go Far" is a rainbow-colored mural he painted in Philadelphia. In it a young girl holds a tree in her hands. Her upraised arms become the tree's roots, high above her head.
Paul Botello began working on murals when he was 8 years old. His older brother, David, is a painter, and Paul used to be his helper. Now, after going to college, Paul does his own murals. His mural "A Shared Hope" appears on the walls of a Los Angeles elementary school. Many of the children in the school are from Central America. The brilliantly colored mural emphasizes the importance of education. It shows a teacher and children. Behind the children are their parents, who help and support them as they learn.
David Botello also started to paint as a boy. Sometimes David works with another painter, but he also paints alone. "Dreams of Flight" is a mural he painted at a public housing project in Los Angeles. It shows a girl playing with a model airplane and a boy flying on a tire swing. Behind them are a great bird, an airplane, an astronaut, a winged horse, and many other vivid images. David hopes the mural lets children know that their dreams can come true.
Murals can tell all kinds of stories. Some reflect political or social ideas. Some entertain. Some make people think. All are one form of artistic expression. They are the people's art.

Copyright © Pearson Education.

 
   
Close  
Fluency Help students read sentences with appropriate pausing. For example, the first sentence on p. 346 should be read: David Botello / the older brother of Paul / loved to paint / and dreamed of / becoming an artist. Make sure students do not "chunk" "loved to paint and dreamed" because this changes the meaning of the sentence.
ELL